First off: I like the idea. Sure it's nothing too new, but that doesn't mean it's completely overused either. It's also well executed and fitting. The composition is great too. Others might argue that the widescreen format pulls the attractions away from the puddle itself, but i like it for that exact fact. For me the effect is just strong enough to make me wonder what may lie beyond, but not too strong to make me completely miss the original core. The visualization is pretty good, especially the contrast between the crisp asphalt and the smooth reflection makes for a great stylistic device. The yellow (paint?) however is a little too distracting in my opinion. Still this is not entirely your "fault" since you obviously cannot move the puddle and definitely a better choice than to crop it out and cut away a part of the puddle too. Impact was only medium, i did click on it when browsing "recent" tho, so that's allright. It's definitely an interesting image, i'm only missing the great "aha"-effect.